View topic - kana problem
kana problem
6 posts
• Page 1 of 1
kana problem
ok so let's see...my questions are about the combination letters:
you combine shi+ya/yo/yu to get sha,sho,shu...but I've seen other books where you combine shi+ya/yo/yu and you get sya,syo,syu...which one is the correct?
also, can you combine chi+small "e" to get che? I've seen it there too
and also, can you ten-ten the "u" letter to get a "v" letter and combine it with all 5 vowels to get va,vi,vu,ve,vo?
I'm really confused
you combine shi+ya/yo/yu to get sha,sho,shu...but I've seen other books where you combine shi+ya/yo/yu and you get sya,syo,syu...which one is the correct?
also, can you combine chi+small "e" to get che? I've seen it there too
and also, can you ten-ten the "u" letter to get a "v" letter and combine it with all 5 vowels to get va,vi,vu,ve,vo?
I'm really confused
-

Riley - Posts: 37
- Joined: Mon 01.31.2005 11:12 am
RE: Romaji
To answer your question, both systems are correct because romaji doesn't count anyway. I think romaji should only be used to learn hiragana. Once you master hiragana, you will know exactly how to pronounce any letter.
On this website, I chose to write しょ as sho in romaji instead of syo because phonetically it is easier for English speakers to guess the correct pronunciation. Most people who write syo are Japanese because they are thinking of how it is actually written SHI plus YO. Both are correct - one more phonetically and one more the way it is constructed. But again, try to leave romaji behind as quickly as possible.
V's aren't used in Japanese except for foreign words. But you are right to make the V sound you ten-ten the u - for example ヴぇ for VE. But this is very rarely used.
I hope this helps some.
On this website, I chose to write しょ as sho in romaji instead of syo because phonetically it is easier for English speakers to guess the correct pronunciation. Most people who write syo are Japanese because they are thinking of how it is actually written SHI plus YO. Both are correct - one more phonetically and one more the way it is constructed. But again, try to leave romaji behind as quickly as possible.
V's aren't used in Japanese except for foreign words. But you are right to make the V sound you ten-ten the u - for example ヴぇ for VE. But this is very rarely used.
I hope this helps some.
-

clay - Site Admin
- Posts: 2806
- Joined: Fri 01.21.2005 9:39 am
- Location: Florida
RE: kana problem
yes indeed
now some things make sense to me
thanks again
thanks again
-

Riley - Posts: 37
- Joined: Mon 01.31.2005 11:12 am
RE: kana problem
This makes me confused? Could 'cha, chu & cho' then be written: cya, cyu & cyo? Seems like it's not even the same sound.
- Daisuke
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1065
- Joined: Wed 02.02.2005 5:20 am
RE: kana problem
Daisuke wrote:
This makes me confused? Could 'cha, chu & cho' then be written: cya, cyu & cyo? Seems like it's not even the same sound.
My point above is romaji causes the confusion. If at all possible lose romaji as soon as you can. :@
CHA, CHU, and CHO are written phonetically (the same romaji system I use on this website) but they really are ち CHI plus small や ya = ちゃ CHA. I write with a C because it sounds like the english CH. But CYA, CYU, and CYO are written based on how they are constructed ち CHI plus small や ya.
-

clay - Site Admin
- Posts: 2806
- Joined: Fri 01.21.2005 9:39 am
- Location: Florida
RE: kana problem
Ohh.. Now i understand. Thank you. 
- Daisuke
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1065
- Joined: Wed 02.02.2005 5:20 am
6 posts
• Page 1 of 1
Return to Grammar Questions and Problems
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests







Click to sign up
