View topic - Spoke
Your question about 'o' vs. 'ga' is a good one.
There are a rare few verbs that tend to take 'ga' where we as English speakers would expect 'o'.
'wakaru' (i.e. 'wakarimasu') is one of them.
I've read it explained as "in fact, wakaru doesn't mean 'to understand'; it actually means '(of meaning etc) to be clear (to sb.)', 'to be understandable (to sb.)".
Then you'd have
nihongo ga wakarimasu ka = Is Japanese understandable (to you)?
It's probably easier just to remember that wakarimasu uses ga and not worry about the details, though; the above translation gives the impression that the original Japanese is clunky, which it's not. "[x] ga wakarimasu" is a very natural way of saying "I understand [x]" in Japanese, so it's best translated with something equally natural in English.
I don't think 'o' vs 'ga' comes up all that often.
- Posts: 493
- Joined: Tue 11.20.2007 2:26 pm
- Native language: English
- Gender: Male
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 10 guests