0 Comments

October 30, 2022

Using 遊びに行く and when の and が are interchangeable

Let’s go through two sentences from this week’s Nihongo no Tane. (See the video of the entire podcast at the bottom)

While this podcast is best for intermediate students of Japanese (and aggressive upper beginners), we'll use it today as a lesson for beginners and upper beginners. I’ll list the vocabulary for the sentences, but the main purpose for today’s lesson is to focus on a single useful phrase or grammatical pattern.


Phrase #1: Using (あそ)びに()く [Beginners]

If you are beginner, here is a great phrase to remember: (あそ)びに()

先日(せんじつ)、お友達(ともだち)(うち)(あそ)びに()きました。

The other day I went to visit a friend.

First, let’s look at the vocabulary and understand the sentence structure.

  • 先日(せんじつ) the other day
  • 友達(ともだち) friend (polite) [the お is for politeness]
  • の ‘s [limits the “house” to that of “friend”: friend’s house]
  • (うち) house
  • に to (the house)
  • (あそ)びに()きました to go visit [(あそ)び is the masu stem form of (あそ)ぶ (to play); に (for the purpose of; notice this に isn’t the directional particle, but rather indicates purpose or reason); ()きました is the polite past of ()く (to go)]

In this sentence, we encounter a very useful expression.  (あそ)びに()く (to go and visit a friend).

Literally, this means “to go for the purpose of playing” and while it could mean to go out to play a sport or game, it is most often used to mean to visit a friend’s house or to go on a fun trip.

Here is a short sentence to memorize. The best way to learn how to use a particular grammatical pattern or set phrase is to memorize useful sentences that you can actually use. (And then actually use them...)

This example is one way to politely invite someone over. Notice it uses a negative form for politeness: won’t you…?

明日(あした)(あそ)びに()きませんか?

tomorrow | for the purpose of play | won’t come | ?

Won’t you come and see me tomorrow?



Phrase #2: Using の in place of が  [Upper Beginners/Intermediates]

Here, Yumi is talking about how she thought only those with the greatest physical endurance would win at tug-of-war.

体力(たいりょく)のある(ほう)持久力(じきゅうりょく)のある(ほう)()ったのかなと(おも)いました。

I thought that the one with more physical strength and endurance would win.

Vocabulary:

  • 体力(たいりょく)のある to have physical strength; to have stamina; to have physical endurance [体力(たいりょく) deals with the body’s 体 strength 力]
  • (ほう) the direction of; the one with
  • 持久力(じきゅうりょく)のある to have stamina; to have tenacity [While similar to 体力(たいりょく), 持久力(じきゅうりょく) means overall endurance: 持 (have; hold) + 久 (long time) + 力 (power)]
  • ()った won [past plain form of ()つ (to win)]
  • のかな I wonder if [the の acts as a nominalizer (makes the previous phrase into a noun phrase) so she can “wonder” about it.]
  • (おも)いました I think [past polite of (おも)う (to think)]

In this example, I want to zero in on the first two phrases. The 体力(たいりょく)のある(ほう) (one with physical stamina)  and 持久力(じきゅうりょく)のある(ほう) (one with tenacity)

Maybe you are wondering what the の is doing there. The trick is the の is really acting like a が here.

体力(たいりょく)ある(ほう)

the one with physical stamina

This could be:

体力(たいりょく)ある(ほう)

the one with physical stamina

In other words, the の and が are interchangeable here, but that isn't always the case.

You can only use の if the phrase modifies a noun. Since we have a noun here ((ほう)), you can use の or が.

So the rule is:

  • If the phrase is modifying (placed before) a noun, の can be used in place of が
  • If there isn’t a noun, you must use が

For example: That person has physical stamina. (Notice there isn't a noun after the phrase)

O あの(ひと)体力(たいりょく)がある。 (Correct)

X あの(ひと)体力(たいりょく)のある。 (incorrect)

But when the phrase is before a noun, you can use either:

O 体力(たいりょく)のある(ほう) (correct)

O 体力(たいりょく)がある(ほう) (correct)

This episode should be live later today. Or check out the video version right now.

Sharing is caring!

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Level up your Japanese!

free-kanji-or-hiragana-offer-final

For Total Beginners

Japanese for beginners - Beri-Beri Shoshinsha

This 15-book study guide + worksheets bundle is ON SALE. For just one-time payment only, you will get this bundle for a very low price plus you will get future contents for free (no additional charge).

Easy to follow and understand

This bundle is perfect for absolute beginners. It's thorough without being wordy, giving you exactly enough information to understand the concepts without overloading you with information. 

TheJapanShop.com Customer

Makoto+ Membership

You'll notice many TheJapanesePage.com lessons have bonus content for Makoto+ Members. Well, membership goes well beyond that. Members also get our monthly magazine for learners of Japanese (Beginners to Intermediates), weekly exclusive lessons, Podcast bonus content, and much more.

>